UK Supreme Court: “Transgender People Can Never Be Women, No Access to Female-Only Spaces or Benefits”

UK Supreme Court: “Transgender People Can Never Be Women, No Access to Female-Only Spaces or Benefits”
London, April 16, 2025
(Associated Press Report)

In a landmark ruling, the UK Supreme Court has declared that the word “woman” legally refers only to someone who is biologically female by birth, effectively excluding transgender women from that definition. The decision comes after a long legal battle between the Scottish Government and the feminist group For Women Scotland.

 Trans Women Barred from Female-Only Spaces

A unanimous five-judge bench ruled that even if a transgender woman possesses a legal Gender Recognition Certificate, she will not be eligible for female-only spaces and protections under the Equality Act. This includes changing rooms, safe houses, swimming areas, medical or counseling services, and other women-specific provisions.

 “Common Sense Has Returned,” Say Supporters

Susan Smith, co-director of For Women Scotland and lead petitioner, said:

“Everyone knows what sex is. It cannot be changed.”

Supporters celebrated outside the court, popping champagne bottles and chanting, “Women’s rights are human rights.”

Famous author J.K. Rowling, who supported the case and donated a substantial sum to the group, posted on X (formerly Twitter):

“With this victory, they have protected the rights of women and girls across the UK.”

 Uproar Among Trans Rights Advocates

The group Scottish Trans called the ruling “a blow and a disappointment”, warning that it undermines the 2004 Gender Recognition Act. Scottish Green Party MSP Maggie Chapman said the ruling sends “a chilling message for human rights.”

Amnesty International released a statement warning that the ruling may violate human rights laws and “legitimize discrimination against trans people.”

Government Welcomes Ruling

The UK Government welcomed the decision, stating:

“This ruling protects female spaces and ensures the safety of women.”

The Scottish Government also acknowledged the court’s decision. First Minister John Swinney said:

“We will consider the implications of this ruling and remain committed to protecting the rights of all.”

 A Precedent with Global Ripples?

Critics argue this ruling could increase stigma and discrimination against transgender individuals. Supporters claim it restores “reality and safety” to women’s spaces. Legal experts suggest the UK decision could influence future rulings across Europe and beyond.